I might suggest something along the lines of my Bordertown Lager which is dark (ish) and mildly-to-moderately hopped. You could change the recipe, clearly to use more hops if everyone liked that idea. I suggest this beer because it's forgiving and I have never had it come out less than stellar. A helles and possibly even a CAP (although I like the idea of a CAP) might be tough for a first lager but that doesn't mean you couldn't attempt it. I would think that your takeaway from a first lager would be observing its slow fermentation, its ability to throw off some aromas that you might not encounter with an ale, the experience of doing a d-rest and also tasting a beer made with a yeast you may have never used before. Styles to attempt might include bock, marzen/festbier, dunkel, dark lager, amber lager kind of thing... think SA Boston Lager or similar, red lager, Jamil's Vienna or something along those lines. Beers to potentially put off until you're more comfortable might be helles, pilsner, American lager, etc. Just a thought. I'm a stubborn, hard-headed, slow-learning simpleton and I whiffed on many, many gold lagers. Just my 2¢. Either way.... I'm in on whatever beer you guys choose.
EDIT: The recipe on my site for Fest Marzenbier is nice too. 2206 is a very nice and distinctly different German style yeast. I made that beer in the spring and had it over the summer and some buds of mine (she is of German ancestry and still has family in Germany and they have been to Oktoberfest many times) were over and drank this beer all day and I kept hearing WOW!s and GREAT BEER!s from both of them.
Edited by KenLenard, 23 December 2013 - 08:08 AM.